I merged your threads to keep replies in one place so it is easier for you to keep track of.
You might want to bookmark this thread so you can find it again later on.

A few have had a nerve nicked during surgery, I don't recall any cut rotator cuff ligaments being posted about..

Did it take 3 years for this to be figured out? How did PT figure it out?

I would find an impartial surgeon , take records and surgical notes, and get some second opinions..