jackh123,

Welcome to NeuroTalk.

I'm confused. You said this neuro was the best in the business but are asking whether you should get a second opinion. So, it sounds like you are doubting him.

My advice is to not waste your time with neuros. They can not do anything to help you. Besides, it sounds like you are planning on more concussions.

This best in the business neuro is obviously ignorant of the fact that 85% of concussions include an upper neck injury. Your description of the hit suggests this is likely.

To be blunt, if a hard hand slap to the head has caused you this must problem, it suggests your brain is sensitive to impacts and likely has already experienced enough trauma to leave you in a weakened state. I doubt you will get much support here for returning to contact training. Even the best head gear will not protect you.

My best to you.