I guess I am the worse sinner here. I found some old broken down crosses and tossed them. It did, for just a moment feel strange throwing Jesus into my garbage can. But, hey, this is how I look at it. If it didn't mean much and it's broke why keep it? It's just a symbol right? And yes, I have religious plaques, crosses and framed images all over my house.

In your case, this was your mom's and is special to you regardless of your beliefs. I say super glue him back on. :-)