My DD made all her boyfriends blankeys from fleece. You've probably seen the ones that are fringed all the way around. All you have to do is be handy with scissors.

There is such a variety of cute fleece nowadays, and it is so inexpensive. WalMart has lots.

I love the ones that I have received. When I lay down for a nap, I think of that person! Even the one that DD's boyfriend made for HER!!! (I inherited it!)

Good luck and let us know what you decide to make!