It would be a great idea to get a second opinion! My herniation was about the same as yours but the surgery was necessary because of the symptoms. I went to Mayo clinic, Madison WI, Milwaukee, Cinncinatti, Indiana and Chicago. Not to mention the local doctors. It was in little ole Indiana that I was diagnosed and in Kenucky where I had the surgery! I now see DR. Frim in Chicago as does my Daughter. He performed her surgery. and My Shunt surgeries. My oldest has it but with no symptoms right and her tonsil is at 4 mm so she does not need surgery. My Nephew started having some problems and Dr. Frim is going to look at his MRI soon. Hang in there and don't give up! Your not crazy and we all know how bizarre these symptoms can be. Take care Lori T.