View Single Post
Old 10-17-2010, 08:10 AM
Concussed Scientist Concussed Scientist is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: England
Posts: 150
15 yr Member
Concussed Scientist Concussed Scientist is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: England
Posts: 150
15 yr Member
Default What is PCS on a pathological or physical level?

Hi Hattie,

I am really sorry to hear what you are going through.
I also have had a car crash and suffered post-concussion symptoms afterwards. Given that everyone is different genetically, our brains are different and the traumas suffered are different, it is remarkable that so many post-concussions symptoms are so similar and so easily recognisable by those of us unfortunate enough to suffer from them.

"Nauseous, dizzy and headachey" you say. This sounds all to familiar and though you might find the symptoms difficult to describe to those who haven't suffered from them. Those of us who have know exactly what you are talking about.

So: "Is it something physically wrong with the brain or not?"
Yes, it is. Definitely.


So if someone tells you that there is nothing physically wrong with your brain, perhaps what they ought to say is that there is nothing physical that could be detected with a brain scan i.e. with the resolution available with an MRI all your brain parts would look undamaged.

However, you cannot see individual neurons with an MRI, nor can you detect biochemical changes what can occur in a trauma. Psychology tests are done by psychologists and a psychologist will tend to give explanations of a patient's condition in terms of what they know i.e. they may give a psychological explanation or they may say that the symptoms likely have a neurophysiological or biochemical cause which is outside of their expertise.

I have had two sets of neuropsychology tests. The first was one year after the car crash and most of my results put me, like you, in a high percentile. Interestingly, the one that was not was my processing speed, interestingly also like you. I have just had the neuropsychology test redone (nearly three years after the accident) and my processing speed seems to have returned to normal. Hopefully you processing speed will also improve with time.

On reading: I didn't have much problem after my accident with reading normal text. However, I had experiences very similar to yours whenever I tried to read music. I play the piano, not very well. But after the accident I could play only about one page of music before it made "me feel so nauseous, dizzy and headachey that I just have to stop." I quote from your experience trying to read text. Mine were the same when I tried to read piano music.

As I do not read piano music very well and certainly not as easily as I can read text. I suppose the extra effort that my brain had to make was just too much for it. This too has greatly improved over the last 3 years. You are much younger than me, so it shouldn't take you so long.

All the best,
CS


Quote:
Originally Posted by Hattie View Post
Hi everyone,

It's now been 8/9 months since my injury and PCS is still a huge daily problem for me. I went for a neuropschological aseessment a few weeks ago and just got the results.

It confirmed that what I was suffering was genuinely PCS even though I had been told this by both my own doctor and a neurologist. However it says also that there is no damage or injury to the brain. What I don't understand therefore, is exactly what PCS is on a pathological or physical level? Is it something physiscally wrong with the brain or not? And if it isn't, why is it there and cause these problems?

Certain aspects of my neuropsych results are really good, my verbal comprehension and communication for example which was in the 95 percentile (so better than 95% of people?). However, areas like my performance IQ was 14 and my processing speed was in the 4th percentile. So my thought is there is clearly something wrong there, but if they say it's not physical damage then I'm wondering what it is.

On a slightly separate note the thing that I've found near on impossible since my injury is reading. I can read for about 10/15 minutes before it makes me feel so nauseous, dizzy and headachey that I just have to stop. I've been trying to build up reading for slightly longer periods of time but it just makes me feel so awful. I can read broken up text or short things but paragraphs and books are another realm entirely.

Unfortunately for me I'm in the middle of a literature degree, albeit on a break until this all gets a bit better. I'm worried about being able to go back. Has anyone had similar reading problems, and if so, how have you adapted to get around them?

Thanks,
Hattie xxx
Concussed Scientist is offline   Reply With QuoteReply With Quote