I am going to assume this conversation and the related thread is based on an "impression" of what suicide is. The converstaion and the original post sounds so matter of fact without understanding of this topic.

Suicide or the thought of suicide is neither passive or active --- IT IS A STATE OF MIND.

You are assuming a person is rational at the time of suicide...so very wrong.

The person who commits suicide is in a very dark place, a place where there is no hope, no way out. Irrational thinking from a very dark and irrational place...their own mind.

Before starting this type of topic make sure you understand what you are talking about.