umm....
what about Amtrak, Donna? had you thought about it?
for trip planning:
www.amtrak.com
you can click
Find a station, then
Search by state to find the nearest station.
there look to be a good many stations in michigan... fewer in indiana... here are the lists, if you just want to get a quick look (but the station links inside these lists will not take you back to trip planner).
Indiana Stations
Michigan Stations
don't know there are close enough ones for you for both departure and arrival? that way you'd only have to get rides to the stations and back. not sure how costly it is but i'd think cheaper than flying.
~ waves ~