Got up this morning all ready for my hot cup of coffee and guess what?

The button I press to make my coffee maker brew coffee popped off when I pressed it!

Luckily, the thing still brewed a pot of coffee but I'm out of luck for tomorrow morning. Guess it'll have to be tea for me until I can get another one.
I'm sure I'll cave under the pressure and buy a cheap-o one at Publix until I can get a better one. But the one that just broke was a cheap-o one - well, it was a Mr. Coffee - but it only cost about $20 and it lasted for nearly 2 years.
Anybody have any suggestions for a good model that will last but doesn't require new car financing type payments?