Scrubbs,
You keep saying "Part B Supplement Provider". Is a "Part B Supplement Provider" and "Medigap Policy" the same thing?

If it is, then I only have the one Medigap Policy choice because I am under 65, which is the one that will cost me almost $500 per month.

I know the clock is ticking. I've been trying to figure this out for the last three weeks and as soon as I think I've got it, something trips me up all over again

It really shouldn't be this difficult and honestly it's past the point of ridiculous to me.