I am a spine patient too. Welcome to Neuro Talk. I came here just as you did searching for answers and knowledge. Before you select surgery, make sure you get two more independant evaluations.
I do think you have reason to be concerned about the large herniations, which are impeding proper cord function. Anytime there is compression on the cord, and or nerve root, it hurts, alot.....
I was in the same position and am fused C3-7. I had two surgeries, for me well worth the pain I went through. I am sorry that you have these issues, but you did find a great place to help you through it. I was hysterical and crying when I first found NT. Pain was horrible. Just make sure, you have several docs. that concur with the dx. I will be here for you and so will NT. Leesa is the best in my opinion about reading the MRI in clear language. I hope she responds to you and can help with the MRI report. ginnie