Hi knowledge hungry;

Yes surgery should be a last resort --but yours are very large herinations and I think you may end up like a few of us on here with spinal fusion(acdf) from c4-7--i had it done 2010 I dont have regrets at all. It gave me my life back. How bad is your pain??? I was in really bad shape before surgery pain was mind blowing . I wont sugar coat---- with those size herinations--- i have a feeling surgery may be your best option. Most important are you getting pain down arms with fingers going numb?---This surgery its done for neurlogical reasons to prevent perm nerve damage. However-- most of the time it provides great pain relief too. I agree always get 2 consults. I wish you all the best!!! Feel free to ask more ? if you like.