FAQ/Help |
Calendar |
Search |
Today's Posts |
04-09-2008, 01:05 AM | #1 | |||
|
||||
Magnate
|
Commentary: What is this thing called religion?
* 05 April 2008 * From New Scientist Print Edition. Subscribe and get 4 free issues. * A. C. Grayling AS LONG as religion was untouchably sacred, it was by definition beyond the prying fingers of objective inquiry. Now society has matured enough to empirically scrutinise religion, and late last year a group of nine European universities led by the University of Oxford began to examine religious belief and behaviour, helped by a ¬2 million European Commission grant. The project, called Explaining Religion (EXREL), brings together psychology, biology, anthropology and history to investigate both the common and the variable features of "religiosity" (this is the term EXREL uses) and to test theories about it - including the current leader in the field, which is that religiosity exists because of the way that human cognitive architecture functions. According to EXREL's website, the project partners "aim to develop a computational model of religious dynamics that can be used to explain present and past religious traditions, and to simulate likely future directions". This is a fascinating and worthwhile project, and is sure to be controversial, whatever its outcome. Illumination may come from seeing how differently the brains of religious and non-religious people function in appropriate experimental circumstances as revealed by fMRI and PET scanning. It is surely relevant that there are such interesting correlations as those between dopamine levels in the brain and degree of religiosity - the more severe a person's Parkinson's disease, the less religious he or she tends to be - but a crucial aspect of the investigations will be the historical and anthropological data, because they affect from the outset what the investigation's target actually is. Comment subject...make a comment to the article READ more
__________________
You're alive. Do something. The directive in life, the moral imperative was so uncomplicated. It could be expressed in single words, not complete sentences. It sounded like this: Look. Listen. Choose. Act. ~~Barbara Hall I long to accomplish a great and noble tasks, but it is my chief duty to accomplish humble tasks as though they were great and noble. The world is moved along, not only by the mighty shoves of its heroes, but also by the aggregate of the tiny pushes of each honest worker. ~~Helen Keller |
|||
Reply With Quote |
04-09-2008, 06:10 PM | #2 | |||
|
||||
Senior Member
|
I recall a PBS program profiling a young man (~17 yrs of age) who became obsessively religious whnever he experienced temporal lobe seizure activity. Intervals in which his seizure activity was controlled, he did not exhibit religiosity.
__________________
In the last analysis, we see only what we are ready to see, what we have been taught to see. We eliminate and ignore everything that is not a part of our prejudices. ~ Jean-Martin Charcot The future is already here — it's just not very evenly distributed. William Gibson |
|||
Reply With Quote |
04-09-2008, 06:56 PM | #3 | ||
|
|||
Member
|
fascinating - but kinda strange premise, don't you think? Like the worse one's condition is, maybe the more one feels - quite rationally - that there's not much to have faith in? I mean we need a scientific study to figure that one out? These guys slay me sometimes.... But still very interesting. Thanks for bringing that in...
|
||
Reply With Quote |
04-09-2008, 07:01 PM | #4 | |||
|
||||
In Remembrance
|
So, is it that god drains away along with the dopamine? Or is it that religious belief lowers stress hormones and produces a healthier individual?
__________________
Born in 1953, 1st symptoms and misdiagnosed as essential tremor in 1992. Dx with PD in 2000. Currently (2011) taking 200/50 Sinemet CR 8 times a day + 10/100 Sinemet 3 times a day. Functional 90% of waking day but fragile. Failure at exercise but still trying. Constantly experimenting. Beta blocker and ACE inhibitor at present. Currently (01/2013) taking ldopa/carbadopa 200/50 CR six times a day + 10/100 form 3 times daily. Functional 90% of day. Update 04/2013: L/C 200/50 8x; Beta Blocker; ACE Inhib; Ginger; Turmeric; Creatine; Magnesium; Potassium. Doing well. |
|||
Reply With Quote |
04-09-2008, 07:21 PM | #5 | ||
|
|||
In Remembrance
|
As Penelope Cruz asked her friend in Bandidas - how does the author know that? Did he ask everyone in the world?
I think all old and dying people lose something that was there due to dying, not lack of faith. You hope like heck something's there, but you don't have the focus or energy to do the outward "religious" things. I find the article complete bull crap, totally presumptuous and arrogant. He should stick to science. paula
__________________
paula "Time is not neutral for those who have pd or for those who will get it." |
||
Reply With Quote |
04-09-2008, 07:50 PM | #6 | |||
|
||||
Member
|
I just finished reading one of the many "brain books" that have recently been written on the subject of aging brains and how to keep them as functional as possible. (Of course the definitive answer is: you must give it lots of exercise.) I view everything through the prism of PD because that's where I'm coming from. The Placebo effect is believed to be powerful because of the belief we have that we are the beneficiary of something that will help us.
There is not much doubt left in the minds of even the most hardened scientific thinker that our brains and the abstract but detectable operation of the effect of what we think about has the power to change things on a physiological level. Thus we have hard science come face to face with religion. The placebo effect must be the positive side of a two sided coin. If what we believe can produce the placebo effect, its flip side must be capable of much havoc. Religion, for the most part, pushes us to have faith, hope and to believe in something much bigger than ourselves. For those that possess this intangible diamond or even only some small portion, it lightens the load. "Religion" is just a word. You can call it spirituality, belief in a higher power or whatever you want to call it, but it is real and powerful and that is why it is a benefit.
__________________
I would never die for my beliefs because I might be wrong. Bertrand Russell |
|||
Reply With Quote |
"Thanks for this!" says: | vertigo (04-10-2008) |
04-09-2008, 08:15 PM | #7 | ||
|
|||
In Remembrance
|
Rosebud,
Thank you - you just made the argument, from science's point of view, that placebos are unnecessary. Tha'ts what we have been saying..... paula
__________________
paula "Time is not neutral for those who have pd or for those who will get it." |
||
Reply With Quote |
04-09-2008, 08:21 PM | #8 | |||
|
||||
Senior Member
|
Paula - but wouldn't that mean that people who don't believe in a higher power would still benefit from a placebo?
__________________
Carey “Cautious, careful people, always casting about to preserve their reputation and social standing, never can bring about a reform. Those who are really in earnest must be willing to be anything or nothing in the world’s estimation, and publicly and privately, in season and out, avow their sympathy with despised and persecuted ideas and their advocates, and bear the consequences.” — Susan B. Anthony |
|||
Reply With Quote |
04-09-2008, 08:37 PM | #9 | ||
|
|||
In Remembrance
|
i was thinking that scientists or non- believing scientists, would consider mortal humans as capable of saving themselves - no spiritual necessary- and that faith is the placebo. How does this help anything? It's a worthless and some would say dangerous placebo and not necessary. It's trickery. As many placebos are.
paula
__________________
paula "Time is not neutral for those who have pd or for those who will get it." |
||
Reply With Quote |
04-09-2008, 09:05 PM | #10 | |||
|
||||
Senior Member
|
but the placebo effect is not about what the doctor or scientist believes, it's about what the patient believes.
understanding that there is a placebo effect, whether it be induced by a sugar pill, sham surgery, or belief in a higher power is not trickery - it's science learning about what makes human beings work. God doesn't work for everyone; neither does a sugar pill.
__________________
Carey “Cautious, careful people, always casting about to preserve their reputation and social standing, never can bring about a reform. Those who are really in earnest must be willing to be anything or nothing in the world’s estimation, and publicly and privately, in season and out, avow their sympathy with despised and persecuted ideas and their advocates, and bear the consequences.” — Susan B. Anthony |
|||
Reply With Quote |
"Thanks for this!" says: | Thelma (04-10-2008) |
Reply |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Anyone know of "hiccup" forum for severe, long lasting hiccups? | Gluten Sensitivity / Celiac Disease | |||
"The Bipolar Handbook" & "Horror Movie Hallucinations" | Bipolar Disorder | |||
ALS is called the "devil's disease" | ALS News & Research | |||
Tomorrow I do the "B" thing!! | Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy (RSD and CRPS) | |||
"Instant Karma" - the Voices of Apathy -"Coulter and Limbaugh" | Parkinson's Disease |