![]() |
Nuclear Stress Test and body-wide CRPS spread
Hello everyone,
I ran across a couple articles about the spread of CRPS through the blood stream by vasoactive chemicals released into the blood stream. www.suite101.com/article.cfm/pns/17374/1 www.suite101.com/article.cfm/pns/17374/2 It implies that vasoactive agents occur as result of kallikreins, or by injury thus producing endothelin which is responsible for vasodialation and constriction. Vasoconstriction causes hypoxia of affected tissue the first noticable sign of RSD. Well my RSD spread body wide from the onset of burning in my limb within one week. This happened about six weeks after my surgery. I had petchia on my lower limb about 2 weeks after surgery. Doctors think I am quacked because I have told them the CRPS is everywhere. I have burning and cold water sensations inn my veins. I had an accute incident of broncioles dialation, I have pulse rate increase and blood pressure fluctuations. My chest gets tight often. Long story short. My Dr wanted me to do another stress test, a "chemical stress test". The thought of injecting anything into my blood stream again scared me. Then the thought hit me. I had a "chemical stress test" the day before my surgery and a vasoactive agent is what is used in the test. I started looking at the common drugs used in chemical stress test and low and behold, some affect the sympathetic nervous system. These articles imply there may be a cure with the correct drugs if indeed the spread came through a chemical compound through the blood stream. My question I would like to ask everyone is how many people here with body wide RSD or rapid spreading have had a chemical nuclear stress test done before the spread occured? I hope I am on to something and already am talking to DR next week about this. This makes me wonder about vasoactive drugs like blood pressure meds. So simple. I cannot explain such a rapid spread of CRPS unless by something like through chemicals in the blood stream. Looking forward to hearing from you. Maybe someone has already gone down this road before me, let me know. Thanks, Jerie |
Quote:
There is a ton of literature about the role of inflammatory cytokines - immune signalling cells - in the advent of RSD/CRPS. For a brief article, easily accessible to the general reader, check out this piece on the RSDSA site, "Curing Chronic Pain—Hope on the horizon?," Linda Watkins, PhD http://www.rsds.org/Research_Article...icpain_05.html For perhaps the best scientific article on the subject, see, Birklein F, Schmelz M, Neuropeptides, neurogenic inflammation and complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS), Neurosci Letters 2008;437:199-202. http://www.rsds.org/pdfsall/Birklein_Schmelz.pdf There is also literature suggesting that patients who are already under chronic stress at the time of injury have a significantly higher chance of getting RSD/CRPS. (I'll fill in that citation as soon as I can.) The presumed relationship is that chronic stress produces inflammatory cytokines - hence its relationship with heart attacks - and that with a higher cytokine load at the time of injury, one is much more likely to have the neuro-autoimmune reaction that is now known to trigger RSD/CRPS, which in turns induces the production of a whole new batch of pro-inflammatory cytokines, etc. What this leads me to, sadly, is whether by giving you a chemical stress test the day before surgery, your doctors may have raised your cytokine levels, leading to where you are today. So, without knowing more about how this test worked - in detail and particularity - under no circumstances would I repeat the test without talking to a serious CRPS specialist first. In fact, it sounds time to find a new doctor on general principles. And your question on blood pressure drugs is prescient. While endothelial responses are complicated and difficult to explain. For an EXCELLENT article on the subject, check out Regulation of peripheral blood flow in Complex Regional Pain Syndrome: clinical implication for symptomatic relief and pain management, George Groeneweg, Frank JPM Huygen, Terence J Coderre and Freek J Zijlstra, BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders 2009, 10:116 http://www.biomedcentral.com/content...474-10-116.pdf That said, currently available blood pressure medicines (such as calcium channel blockers) do so by simply relaxing vasal tone throughout the body. Which sounds wonderful, until you realize that CRPS can become in short order a disease of profound autonomic dysregulation, leading to neurogenic-vasoconstriction in one part of the body, while giving you edema secondary to vasodilation in another part, at the same time! I in fact had the chance to live this movie when my cardiologist gave me Norvasc - a calcium channel blocker - because it appeared that I was having episodes of cardiac vasospasms, only to have to return a week later with legs that he would later tell me looked like I had elephantiasis! We brought the edema down in about 6 weeks with a lot of Lasix (taken with a prescription potassium supplement, than you) but that's not a long term solution where for each liter of "interstitial fluid" diuretics remove, they take 2 liters of blood out of your system. Not a good recipe for long term kidney health, according to a nephrologist with whom I consulted when it became clear that I couldn't urinate unless I had had a diuretic within the preceding 6 hours. And of course, autonomic-dysregulation well could explain some of your other issues. See, e.g., Complex regional pain syndrome with associated chest wall dystonia: a case report, Irwin DJ, Schwartzman RJ, J Brachial Plex Peripher Nerve Inj. 2011 Sep 26;6:6 http://www.jbppni.com/content/pdf/1749-7221-6-6.pdf AND Atypical chest pain: evidence of intercostobrachial nerve sensitization in Complex Regional Pain Syndrome, Rasmussen JW, Grothusen JR, Rosso AL, Schwartzman RJ, Pain Physician 2009 Sep-Oct;12(5):E329-34 http://www.painphysicianjournal.com/...;E329-E334.pdf See also, Syncope in Complex Regional Pain Syndrome, Smith JA, Karalis DG, Rosso AL et al, Clinical Cardiology, 34:4, April 2011 http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/1.../clc.20879/pdf But back to cytokines, there is one avenue of research, at least for patients whose illness is still immune-modulated (fka "sympathetically maintained") that hasn't bee looked at serious, at least in this country, even though the one published case study I am aware of was written by, among other people, Frank Birklein, MD, a young Dutch scholar who is currently doing some of the most important work going in looking at the immunological aspects of CRPS. Worth a look in any event: Successful intravenous regional block with low-dose tumor necrosis factor-alpha antibody infliximab for treatment of complex regional pain syndrome 1, Bernateck M, Rolke R, Birklein F, Treede RD, Fink M, Karst M, Anesth Analg. 2007 Oct;105(4):1148-51 http://www.anesthesia-analgesia.org/.../1148.full.pdf I hope this is useful. Mike |
different mechanisms of vasoconstriction (long)
Jerie -
I realized that post my hadn't commented on the role of "kallikreins" mentioned in the online article you cited by Les Abrams, whose professional qualifications are not stated. As an initial matter, I learned that kallikreins are defined as "a hypotensive protease that liberates kinins from blood plasma proteins and is used therapeutically for vasodilation." I then ran a PubMed search for "vasoconstriction kallikreins," this was the topped ranked article in English, for which only an abstract is readily available: Mechanisms of disease: the tissue kallikrein-kinin system in hypertension and vascular remodeling, Madeddu P, Emanueli C, El-Dahr S, Nat Clin Pract Nephrol. 2007 Apr;3(4):208-21.Then we have this, AT(2) receptor-dependent vasodilation is mediated by activation of vascular kinin generation under flow conditions, Katada J, Majima M, Br J Pharmacol. 2002 Jun;136(4):484-91. FULL TEXT @ http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/1...jp.0704731/pdf Abstracthttp://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12055126 And finally, we have, The role of the renal kallikrein-kinin system in diabetic nephropathy, Riad A, Zhuo JL, Schultheiss HP, Tschöpe C, Curr Opin Nephrol Hypertens. 2007 Jan;16(1):22-6. FULL TEXT @ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...nihms43252.pdf Abstracthttp://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17143067 And in particular, please see the following paragraph form the PubMedCentral (author's manuscript) version of the last article: Interactions between inhibition of the renin–angiotensin system and activation of the renal kallikrein–kinin systemhttp://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...nihms43252.pdf As I read it, what we have can be boiled down this. There are different forms of vasoconstiction. The most common, that which is in particular associated with diabetes, may be subject to the kallikrein–kinin system. On the other hand, what we are dealing with in RSD/CRPS is something altogether different, neurogenic-vasoconstiction, which is not mediated by the endothelial cells that line the blood vessels, but rather by the autonomic nerves that "enervate" (are profused through the tissue) of all but the smallest of blood vessels, i.e., the capillaries, thereby regulating the "tone" of the vessel, in other words, allowing it to expand or contract as necessary. In support - and in plain English - allow me to submit the following extended excerpt from the (non-copyrighted) Wikipedia article on Blushing: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blushing I apologize for the length of this post, but in the interest of clarity, I thought it important to make the distinction as clearly as possible. Mike |
Quote:
Hi Jerie, You have certainly had a very rough time of it. Please avoid a repeat of this procedure. If your doctor pressures you maybe it is time to seek another opinion. Additionally, if your doctors don't believe that CRPS spreads you must keep looking. If I might add another caution please be very careful with internet sources that you select for guidance in your journey. The material posted by Les Abrams is questionable. Mr. Abrams describes himself as a "researcher" when in fact his professional experience has nothing to do with clinical research. A little hunting revealed that he has some sort of background in computers and prepares blog like material on everything from "plant intelligence" to "consumer issues." He uses no citations to validate his assertions. I only mention this because I have seen other forum members recommend Abrams and it is potentially quite risky. Really do your homework. It is far safer to search Clinical Trials.Gov or Pub Med as Mike quite proficiently and routinely does. Have you exhausted less invasive treatments? Do you have a treatment team open to trying more cutting edge treatments. Although many pain management doctors are knowledgeable in CRPS, many are the one way docs. You are the nail and they are the hammer. You sound like you are already a great self-advocate! Better days are ahead for you! |
Quote:
I have not even gotten of the ground yet .I have no doctor and no treatment plan. I want to do the aggressive attempt to close the sympathetic gate because I had surgery in May this year and I already have CRPS body wide and internal. I also am a recovering alcoholic. I did not survive addiction to live on medication the rest of my life. I am only 51 and I would like to have a little quality of life. I spent most of my life before sobriety in misery. I would like to have some emotional and physical "normal life time" during the rest of my stay on earth. I am still trying to talk a VA anesthesiologist at the pain clinic into helping me. Maybe I should just go inpatient to their Florida hospital that does nothing but pain. The VA doctor said she had RSD experience but I am still not convinced yet. When I came to the visit she wanted to address fibromyalgia and I had called 2 times before my appointment to make sure she knew something about RSD and to affirm I was not coming to discuss fibro, but CRPS. I have been repeatedly under treated and it spread so fast before they even got on board with RSD. If I hadn't taken pictures of my leg when I was having edema and color changes they still would be blowing me off. I probably need more help than she can give me. But I don't want to have to reinvent the wheel every time I see a new doctor. I want to start treatment now. I believe nerve blocks are the best thing to do for my organs considering the issues are wide spread sympathetic burning and cold water sensations in my veins and skin. I only have one kidney. Thanks for the heads up on the researcher. I now need to try to decipher all these articles into laymans terms I can understand. I kind of got the impression that the vasodialation and constriction may not even be related to those particular chemicals noted in Abrims articles in CRPS. Jerie |
Quote:
Thank you so much for all the information. It is pretty much over my head so I will have to take a while and try to digest what all this means. I just started down this path when I saw the blood spread theory because it made sense to me in my case. Like I said I just had a "small still voice moment" when worrying about doing another chemical stress test. One of my first trails was concerning vasodialation as I had bronchioles dilation and flushing up my neck one day and I went and got a toradol shot because my body was freaking out. I started looking at arterioles dilatation due to SNS activity. I do wonder about substance P as I do have fibromyalgia too. Your experience with elephantiasis type symptoms leaves one to be careful what treatment you do and what you let doctors do to you. I appreciate the information. I have to see the anesthesiologist at the pain clinic weds and I need to have an intelligent conversation about the approach I want to take and why. I was thinking a clonidine patch might benefit me because it settles sympathetic activity down, but who knows what blood pressure meds will do to me. I thought alpha and/or beta blockers might help too. Now I am not so sure if I want to go down that trail or not. Right now I have low sodium and high potassium levels. I have high ferritin levels and low blood iron. My calcium level is on the low side and proteins are low too which is weird because I am a meat and dairy heavy diet carnivore. I also eat salt like crazy. It's like I am not absorbing nutrients and they are dumping in the tissues and bones or out of my body. I didn't have protein in my urine though. Nothing but my ferritin level is really that abnormal, the rest is just outside normal ranges. I'm not a scientist, chemist or doctor. I am educating myself as fast as I can because everything I have read indicates prognosis is poor for the kind of symptoms I have. I need to get the SNS turned off asap. I tried antihistamines to see if I got any relief and I didn't. If you have a short story explination I'll take it too. Thanks, jerie |
Quote:
Really quick. It just occurs to me that if the "nuclear/chemical stress test" was simply an [insert name of isotope] blood perfusion study - typically of the heart - where addenosine is used to stimulate cardiac activity, I wouldn't worry about it, I have had them done repeated since getting CRPS and the worst thong I got was an apparently false negative: followed by a small heart attack a few months later. But then I don't understand why a doctor would be wanting to re-administer it within such relatively short period of time. Which would suggest that you may have had another test entirely??? :Scratch-Head: And as far as the other symptoms you describe, I am equally at a loss. Running a search for "ferritin weight loss night sweats" in PubMed gives me four articles, each pertaining different diagnoses, although there appears to be a slight tipping of the scales in favor of rheumatological disorders. Right now, I think the most important thing you can do is to be worked up by a good internist. Not sure whether the VA is up to this or not. But when you before you see your pain specialist next Wednesday, you might want to go onto PubMed at http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?db=PubMed and run the search I suggested or just click on http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed?t...night%20sweats which includes the search terms. Then click on the boxes by each journal reference and hit "Send to" in the upper right portion of the screen. That will produce a small drop-down screen, on which you should click "Email." Doing so lengthens the drop-down screen and gives you more fields. Under format, scroll down to "Abstract" and then beside it check the box "MeSH and Other Data," then enter your email address and under "Additional text," type in "PubMed search results for 'ferritin weight loss night sweats,'" so that the email will be nicely labeled. Then click on the "E-mail" button, which should present a screen with a green check mark at the upper left and the notation “E-mail sent to [email account address].” Then check your email for something from “Sent by NCBI,” open it and you should have a nice page with each of the four abstracts, which you can print out and bring to your appointment. If you have a spam filter in place, check the “Suspect Email” box, or whatever it might be called in your email program. And should your doctor ask you just what type of an internist you had in mind, it couldn’t hurt to start with a rheumatologist. The worst they will do is draw a lot of blood and send it off for analysis. Short of getting you the promised authority on a suggested link between chronic stress at the time of "injury" and CRPS - which I will get you - that's much of what I know. Again, I'm just like you, my formal training in the biological sciences doesn't extend beyond a couple of classes I took in college to satisfy the general degree requirements, on my way to getting a BE in Econ and then a law degree. If I have any advantage it's that 20 years of practicing law made me fairly comfortable with online data bases, skills that transferred with surprising ease into the public medical data search tools ballerina mentioned earlier. Good luck! Mike |
Hi Mike,
I think I may have a couple issues going on and one may be arthritic. I am changing my diet to see if I can get my body to use iron instead of dump it into my bones and tissue. I think Iron overload is a real probability from my animal product diet. It may not even be related to RSD. I did find an interesting article on substance P and neurogentic inflamation in arsenic-induced vascular dysfunction. I had high arsenic in a hair sample done at a naturalpathic doctor along with very high uranium levels. A cross over of issues may need to be addressed. I am getting a radon test for my home and will do a metal toxicity chealation and see what happens next. Thanks for all you help. I appreciate it. I had another disturbing health event this week. I had severe head pain in the back of my head along with severve cold sensations in my left eye and surrounding area. I almost went to the ER. The next day I had double vision in my right eye so bad stop signs were even difficult to read. Hope RSD isn't in my brain. This stuff is weird, very weird. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed?t...%20dysfunction |
your doctor
Dear Jerie -
Thanks for linking me to Involvement of substance P and neurogenic inflammation in arsenic-induced early vascular dysfunction, Chen SC, Tsai MH, Wang HJ, Yu HS, Chang LW, Toxicol Sci. 2007 Jan;95(1):82-8 Epub 2006 Oct 20 http://toxsci.oxfordjournals.org/con.../1/82.full.pdf That said, you don't offer a guess as to how you might have been exposed to arsenic. Then too, uranium and radon, while both radioactive, are two entirely separate elements with distinct chemical properties. To be candid, my suspicion is that your naturalpathic doctor may be selling you a bill of goods. There should however be an easy way to check this out, where either diagnosis would cause major alarm among public health officials. I can't imagine that it would be too much of a problem to arrange for free and independent testing through your county health department. PLEASE do so before giving any more money to this "doctor." You then say: Hope RSD isn't in my brain. This stuff is weird, very weird.Please don't take this the wrong way, but after a few years, CRPS/RSD is literally "all in your head." It is in fact maintained by the brain. The two most prominent articles are The Brain in Chronic CRPS Pain: Abnormal Gray-White Matter Interactions in Emotional and Autonomic Regions, Geha PY, Baliki MN, Harden RN, Bauer WR, Parrish TB, Apkarian AV, Neuron. 2008;60:570-581 http://www.rsds.org/pdfsall/Geha_Baliki_etal.pdf and Abnormal thalamocortical activity in patients with Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS) type I, Walton KD, Dubois M, Llinás RR, Pain 2010 Jul;150(1):41-51, Epub 2010 Mar 24 http://www.rsds.org/pdfsall/Walton_Pain_2010.pdf However, both articles are exceedingly technical. Your best bet may be the "Commentary" that was published to the study by Walton, Dubois and Llinás, Thalamocortical dysrhythmia and chronic pain, Jones EG, Pain 2010 Jul;150(1):4-5. Epub 2010 Apr 14 http://www.rsds.org/pdfsall/JonesEG_Pain_2010.pdf Hey, at least we have a disease that's interesting. That must count for something. Right? Mike |
Hi Mike,
The natropathic dr said they test for naturally occuring uranium and radon is a by product of natrally occuring uranium. He told me to get a radon test done in my house. I would not be at all surprised what is in our water supply in my town. We have TCE contamination and an active plume here, which I lived in the active area for 5 years and didn't even know it. No one drinks the water here. I use to get rashes after showering when I lived at my old house. Arsenic in the water wuld be the first place I looked, or my husband is over me, lol. He suggested a chelation for metals in my report but never pressured me for anything or to buy anything. I did think I needed to retest. It did seem as high as my uranium levels were the health department should have been notified. I'll ask them tommorrow about it. I personally think CRPS is all in the spine and the brain is it's victim. The chicken or the egg? Who knows, it is complex for sure. I bet when they fiugre it out it will be something simple to turn if off. It seems like many factors set it up, but does it really? Maybe we just haven't figured out the common denominator yet. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:01 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
vBulletin Optimisation provided by
vB Optimise (Lite) -
vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.