NeuroTalk Support Groups

NeuroTalk Support Groups (https://www.neurotalk.org/)
-   Fibromyalgia and Chronic Fatigue (https://www.neurotalk.org/fibromyalgia-and-chronic-fatigue/)
-   -   Secondary Fibro? Fibro-like Symptoms? (https://www.neurotalk.org/fibromyalgia-and-chronic-fatigue/21353-secondary-fibro-fibro-symptoms.html)

Idealist 06-07-2007 11:19 PM

Secondary Fibro? Fibro-like Symptoms?
 
Can anyone out there explain to me what terms like that are supposes to mean? I understand that my fibro was caused by the chronic pain I've lived with for five years now. I was diagnosed with the fibro four years ago. So far I have seen twenty-seven doctors and specialists, and they still haven't diagnosed the source of my original pain. But each one of them seems to have a different perspective on fibromyaligia. Some say I have it, others say that it's a secondary condition, so it's not that important. And now I keep hearing that I don't have fibro at all, just "fibro-like reactions to living with pain all the time."

When a Rheumatologist first diagnosed me with fibromyalgia, I researched the condition very thoroughly, and one thing that I read over and over again is that this condition is usually unleashed by some type of physical or mental trauma in the patient's life. Does the fact that the trauma still exists mean that the fibro doesn't? It wouldn't bother me so much except for two reasons. One is that my disability is officially for fibro. And the other is that some of the specialists I go to seem to immediately view me differently when I use the word fibro at all.

Has anyone else had to deal with this problem? I know I can't be the only one who has fibro in conjunction with other illnesses. Have any of you been told that it's not important because something else is worse? I would really love to come up with some effective line to use with these doctors so they would quit making me feel like an idiot.

Thanks A Lot, Everyone,
Idealist

fiberowendy2000 06-08-2007 05:19 AM

Okay primary Fibromyalgia is when there is a catalyst like a car accident causes the issue. For example, a person gets whiplash and hurts themselves. The pain goes away then a few months later FM starts in. That is primary.
Secondary is when you have something like RA or spinal problems and then FM develops. They co-exist while the primary does not co-exist.
Let me share my experience.
I have primary FM. I have no reason for it, no car accident, no pre-existing condition. It just happened. I do have RA in my family and there are reports out there that if there is a family history for RA, then FM is a possibility as well. Aren't I lucky?:D I do have other health issues but the FM came first.
I hope that helps. I know its confusing.

AUGOLDMINER 06-11-2007 10:10 PM

What i have told is primary fibro is when there is no known cause and secondary fibro is fibro after trauma or something like a autoimmune disease.

although this can be misleading in that fibro has so many symptoms that many autoimmune disorders can be missed or not found till years latter.

I my case the autoimmune disorder was not found till 14 months after the fibro started and the very very rare autoimmune disorder i had was a asymptomatic type (castleman's disease) and was found by accident during a CT scan.

One small study of people with primary fibro for over 15 years found that 95% had been DXed with a autoimmune disorder years after there fibro started.
The doctors that did the study believe that these people had the autoimmune disorder all a long but were asymptomatic or the symptoms masked by the fibro and the autoimmune disorder had been missed.

If this is the case then fibro would be a Secondary Autoimmune Disorder.

rashelle 06-12-2007 02:03 AM

As I look back I can see the start of fibro. I was in the hospital a few years ago with kidney stones. They sent me home to pass the stones. I developed a 105 temp. and the stone was star shaped and passing through my ureter. Back to the hospital I went. They did a surgery to basket out the stones. When I woke up the pain was unbearable. I cried and begged for help for four days, I just wanted to die. The Dr. said ,"we are losing you", but we don't Know why. He went in for a second surgery and found the stone had torn my ureter apart. I was all infected inside. I woke up with drains and all kind of stuff all over my body. They worked frantically to elevate my immune system. It took one month in the hospital. As a resolute I got immune deficiency disorder in my eye (herpes). They said it was a staff infection. A wonderful Dr. found it , I almost went blind. I have a permanent stint in my eye. From that point on my immune system has never been right. And now I have Fibro. I know stress is a lot of the pain to, But the stress is not going away for me. I have had fairly good luck with attitudes of Dr.'s, but I demand respect from them. If they bother to ask whats going on in my life, they can see the hell I live in and part of the cause of the fibro. You'll get use to the looks and learn to nip it. The best thing you can do is educate yourself and them. Copy articles you read and take it to them. Talk soon, by.

Idealist 06-12-2007 09:05 PM

Oh, Rashelle...
 
What an awful experience you had! To think that something as common as a kidney stone, even after it's found, could lead to the risk of death or even blindness just sounds extraordinarily incompetent on somebody's part, at least to me unless there were extenuating circumstances.

I'm so sorry you had to go through so much pain and misery, and then be left with medical problems that might last a lifetime, just because of something like that. I do hope that you are much better now, and continue to improve as time goes by. Good luck and my best wishes to you!

nancy-h 06-14-2007 01:36 AM

Rashelle makes a good point!
 
Idealist;

Rashelle makes a good point. You need to continue to educate yourself and continue that education until you are a fibro expert. When I was diagnosed, I was sent to a pain management team. (I also have Idiopathic Peripheral Neuropathy.) One of the docs there told me to get Dr. Devin Starlanyl's book, "The Fibromyalgia Advocate". He told me right up front that some docs still don't recognize fibro as a disease, that these doctors feel that fibro patients have many symptoms that could be attributed to other medical conditions. They also are not comfortable with fibro because there is not a definite test, like a blood or urine test, that tells them a patient has fibro. This is probably the reason why you get funny looks from some of the doctors you have seen. My neurologist is one of these doctors and we had a rather heated discussion about it. I need to read up on where things are headed with fibro because I was told we are getting close to a cure. Now doesn't that beat all - we are close to a cure for a medical condition that doesn't exist! :eek: HA!

Good Luck!
Nancy-H

shiney sue 06-14-2007 01:49 AM

Thanks
 
I for bring this up. And thanks to everybody for explaining it so well. Sue

Idealist 06-14-2007 09:51 PM

Yes, thanks guys for all your wisdom and help. I consider myself fairly well educated about FMS as a condition, but the reason why I am concerned is that mine is not the major problem with me. I have another, undiagnosed condition that causes most of my problems. But since it hasn't been classified yet, my disability is based on my fibro, so it worries me some when the docs start telling me that I don't really have it, even though it was diagnosed in me by a Rheumatologist.

fiberowendy2000 06-15-2007 06:49 AM

Listen to the Rheumy.....he would know best.

nancy-h 06-16-2007 02:01 AM

Wendy is right
 
Listen to your rheumy and as long as his paperwork is done properly along with any and all other docs you see, you should be ok.

nh

coyote 06-20-2007 06:06 PM

As far as the cause of Fibromyalgia goes, there is no official explanation: could be infection (with mycoplasma or other pathogens), stress, childhood or other trauma, spinal cord injury, thyroid problems, etc.
I would go with the rheumy, as others said. My orthopedic doctor doesn't particularly believe in fibro. He calls it polymalgia.
I even had a neurologist who didn't believe in him.
Stay with the docs that help you out.

Dmom3005 02-03-2008 10:13 PM

This is a good thread. I have been looking for one. Trying to understand better.

I have a good doctor just learning this disorder. And wanting to know what I'm doing more.

So thanks and keep adding.

Donna

DizySara 02-04-2008 12:39 AM

From what I've been learning is that Fibro is actually Flouride poisioning. The symptoms are identical. But they will not admit this because of possible law suits. It reminds me of what happened to my father with Agent Orange. They waited till it was to late and no chance of fighting it to admit he had it and how he got it. By time he was properly diagnosed with it he had only 2 yrs left to live. Although Fibro won't kill us so they say. It can be directly connected to flouride poisioning, but they don't tell you this. And most doctors themselves don't make the connection as well.

Secondary, primary. To me it's all a way to keep us in circles so that we don't find the truth behind it all.

Personally I'm not waiting around for a cure from people who've been covering up the cause. I'm trying to find a way to eliminate Flouride from everything I consume. And see if that helps. Although who knows how bad the damage is already done and how much of it's reversible.

Sara

fiberowendy2000 02-04-2008 09:42 AM

Well, Sara you bring up an intrguing idea but I just looked up fluoride poisoning and none of my symptoms are there.
Can you lead me to more information about the FM/fluoride link?

tinkieanne 02-24-2008 05:49 AM

this is to idealist about secondary fm what the others have said is right,but maybe u should go to a neurologist and see what they say i've read that fm is a neuro problem and not related to arthritis.have u checked out mayofascialpain disorder? hope this helps:)?

uncomfortable one 04-22-2008 12:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by nancy-h (Post 113591)
Listen to your rheumy and as long as his paperwork is done properly along with any and all other docs you see, you should be ok.

nh

Hey Nancy, I was just reading over your reply, and I just left a response to someone else about author Devin Starlanyl. He has another book co written with Mary Ellen Copeland titled: Fibromyalgia & Chronic Myofascial Pain (2nd edition). I highly recommend it! I hope that all who have responded gets a grip on their fibro. Don't give up, relief can be achieved. (I hope) LOL:rolleyes:

Idealist 04-23-2008 09:14 PM

Wow, this post is getting old, but it's getting better, too. Tinkieanne, I have been to a neurologist a few times. In fact, so far I've seen 28 doctors and specialists of one kind or another, and been to six hospitals. I do suffer from MPS on occasion, but it usually happens because I tighten myself up so much to minimize the other pain. Thanks for the input. It all makes me think.

DizySara, I've never heard of the flouride connection before. Can you tell me where you read that at? I live out in the country, so our water isn't flourinated. It comes strait from a well. Isn't water the major source of fluoride in most people's diets? I'd love to hear anything else you know on the subject.

I've continued to grow and learn with my conditions, and I put a lot of effort into it. I consider myself rather well-informed. But there are so many opinions out there right now that it would drive Confuscious crazy!

Thanks everyone for all your thoughts and advice. It's a really big help to be able to discuss this with people who really know what I'm talking about.

Idealist

therapydogmom 07-23-2012 12:50 PM

I have fibro and Sjogren's - sometimes hard to know what's going on. But I have found a good rheumy and hope you have a good one, too. I am on permanent disability. Good doctor will keep you safe with that.

Wish you well.

therapydogmom

Mist8012 07-25-2012 12:54 PM

I haven't been diagnosed with Fibromayalgia. I stumbled over for information. I'm 3 months into whiplash despite massage therapy im still in chronic pain.

The last 2 weeks I have neck pain, shoulder pain (spasms), right up to my elbow followed by tingling and numbness and cold hands.

Yesterday was my left arm. I woke up with migraine, neck and shoulder pain but my arms were fine until I tapped my right arm on a door handle and for the last 2 hrs I've been in agony!

hand and arm is freezing cold and numb, tingly and oh so painful.

My doctors is closed today. Could this be Fibro or pinched nerve?

I have all the other cognitive symptoms but I also have post concussion syndrome.

Thanks

Kelly

annie3940 09-09-2012 06:02 PM

not fibro, no such thing...........
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Idealist (Post 110388)
Can anyone out there explain to me what terms like that are supposes to mean? I understand that my fibro was caused by the chronic pain I've lived with for five years now. I was diagnosed with the fibro four years ago. So far I have seen twenty-seven doctors and specialists, and they still haven't diagnosed the source of my original pain. But each one of them seems to have a different perspective on fibromyaligia. Some say I have it, others say that it's a secondary condition, so it's not that important. And now I keep hearing that I don't have fibro at all, just "fibro-like reactions to living with pain all the time."

When a Rheumatologist first diagnosed me with fibromyalgia, I researched the condition very thoroughly, and one thing that I read over and over again is that this condition is usually unleashed by some type of physical or mental trauma in the patient's life. Does the fact that the trauma still exists mean that the fibro doesn't? It wouldn't bother me so much except for two reasons. One is that my disability is officially for fibro. And the other is that some of the specialists I go to seem to immediately view me differently when I use the word fibro at all.

Has anyone else had to deal with this problem? I know I can't be the only one who has fibro in conjunction with other illnesses. Have any of you been told that it's not important because something else is worse? I would really love to come up with some effective line to use with these doctors so they would quit making me feel like an idiot.

I am so sorry you have had to go through all this. I also went through it untill I was allowed to see a fabulous neuroscientist at Mass General. Bottom line, she wrote and article to neruologist.....start looking at the immue system. There are all these new things. Treatment for me was successful. I have small fiber polyneuropathy and ra and low immunse system....ie, i get infusions. My doc is not someone that I can put out here but I can assure you, she thinks they are just calling it that.......good luck ....I also have sjrogens all auto immune diseases that have names

Thanks A Lot, Everyone,
Idealist

I am so sorry you have had to go through all this. I also went through it untill I was allowed to see a fabulous neuroscientist at Mass General. Bottom line, she wrote and article to neruologist.....start looking at the immue system. There are all these new things. Treatment for me was successful. I have small fiber polyneuropathy and ra and low immunse system....ie, i get infusions. My doc is not someone that I can put out here but I can assure you, she thinks they are just calling it that.......good luck ....I also have sjrogens all auto immune diseases that have names


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:34 PM.

Powered by vBulletin • Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

vBulletin Optimisation provided by vB Optimise v2.7.1 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.