[MelodyL]

I thought David Archuletta was so cute, I wanted to pinch his cheeks. He sang GREAT!!!!

Whose your favorite??

You obviously know mine.

[FlyFishin Momma]

David Cook is mine.....he is a homegrown Missouri kid just like me....

The Davids were both Hot tonight I thought. Either one of them could win in my book...

(I am still a huge Carly fan at heart though)

[shiney sue]

Cook yes i'm a Mo girl ,well old lady who loves him to he's got talent and
not bad to look at. The other David is cute but nope not from Mo. Hugs Sue

[SandyC]

And, oh my, poor dreadlocks, he really messed up tonight didn't he? Little David is so cute he could win just standing there lol And Syeesha (sp?) is a cutey, really making her place. I really love her voice.

David Cook is my fav but he was a little off tonight. I think he is so worried about his brother. :-(

[MelodyL]

Yeah. his poor brother has brain cancer. How he got the courage to go through all the American Idol shows, and he's thinking of his brother, well I give him props for that.

As for Jason Castro. I have no idea why he is still on that show.

Alan looks t the tv and shouts. Go and mop the floor with that hair.!!!!

He has NEVER belted out any tunes. He has never even raised his voice. Now Carly Smithson. She was something.

But to me, I can just close my eyes and listen to David Archuletta and just mellow out. I thought he was soooo good last night.

It really should be between the two Davids.

If Jason doesn't go home tonight, I think Alan will shoot the tv!!!!


lol

[Kitty]

I watched it.....seems like David A. was the only one who got brownie points from all the judges. Poor Jason really messed up - it almost seems like all the wind has gone out of his sails. He just seems very unmotivated to do anything beyond the minimum. I'm sure David A or David C will take the title - it'll be between those two.

[MelodyL]

I can only tell you what Alan told me. If Jason Castro is still there tonight, Alan will get up, go over to the tv and kick it.

And Alan really is not supposed to KICK ANYTHING BECAUSE HE'S WEARING THE SHOE BOOT!!!

So I just might have to buy a new tv over this whole debacle.

People seem to think that Jason Castro deliberately muffed the lines.

That he WANTS to go home.

He really doesn't look professional and he doesn't seem to take it all seriously.

Now David Cook, Archuletta and Syesha...well, they DO take it all seriously.

It's going to be very interesting.

I wonder though, why Kelly Clarkson, and the others, have not made any appearances on this season's IDOL!!!!

Where's Taylor Hicks, where's SANJAYA!!!! lol

[hollym]

Originally Posted by MelodyL

People seem to think that Jason Castro deliberately muffed the lines.

That he WANTS to go home.

He really doesn't look professional and he doesn't seem to take it all seriously.

I said this same thing to my DH last night. It seemed like he was trying to screw up. It came across as goofy and jokey. His performance was all really weird to me.

My fav is David Cook, but I love Sayesha and I do really like David A., but sometimes his performances are all too similar - last night he was really good, though.

[SandyC]

I think Jason screwed up after all the judges ripped him a new one. Jim is convinced he's doped up. If he doesn't go home tonight I wont be surprised. He has a huge following and people will still vote for him. That's kind of how it goes these days. I think in the end it will be David vs David.

[soxmom]

Originally Posted by SandyC

I think Jason screwed up after all the judges ripped him a new one. Jim is convinced he's doped up. If he doesn't go home tonight I wont be surprised. He has a huge following and people will still vote for him. That's kind of how it goes these days. I think in the end it will be David vs David.

Jim might be right Sandy...... He sometimes seems just a little toooo
happy. I like when he just kinda laughs when the judges rip
into him.