Originally Posted by LIT LOVE

I was almost approved with first application, at the first stage, but the decision ended up getting yanked and was one of a small percentage to be over turned. It took me a long and complicated journey to reach a Fully Favorable decision. In hindsight, had I simply learned what was important to SS by doing my research in the beginning, I wouldn't have wasted so much time.

Your situation is not all that unusual. Approval at this ALJ hearing, or even after another appeal, is entirely possible.

Without reading your file, it is impossible to guess why you're not being approved. If your attorney is not proactive on your behalf, than you need to be. If you haven't read the Blue and Red books yet, that would be a good place to start.

You've written that your ALJ has a high denial rate, so maybe you should consider changing your Alleged Onset Date voluntarily to when you turned either 50 or 55--this would lower the threshold for your approval based on the grid rules. But, whatever you decide, going into the hearing with the attitude that it's a waste of time and being hostile to the ALJ, will not help your case.

Originally Posted by Rayandnay

My problem is that keep drawing judges with very low approval rates, not very intelligent, because the appeals council keeps sending it back. The judge that sent me on my CE exam which included a IQ and Memory Scale exam has 66% approval rating, so I'm cautiously optimistic. My remand order from appeals council only wants one thing cleared up, their doctors words, one says severe, the other says mild to moderate.

Originally Posted by LIT LOVE

So, this is a new ALJ?

Do you have any documentation that your function has not decreased since your initial application? That will likely be the sticking point, you may now qualify based on the CE exam, but are you entitled to benefits going back to your original Alleged Onset Date?

If you're willing to take less backpay, you might be able to have your attorney negotiate an On the Record decision... Of course there is also the possibility the ALJ will give you a Fully Favorable On the Record decision, but you should have the dates worked out ahead of time if you're willing to "settle" (it's inappropriate terminology in this context but nonetheless, that is what it is).

Originally Posted by Rayandnay

Right now as we speak my attorney is getting up to date information from my physchiatrist who I see often, they just got the results of CE exam today, not quite sure what the game plan is. Oddly enough, I called the 800 number for social security a few days ago, and the representative I talked to, just to get update was shocked this case has gone on so long. We already amended onset date from 2006 to 2009. The ball is in their court.

Originally Posted by LIT LOVE

Those employees at the 800 # are not as informed or as well trained as those at the local offices. I'm not sure they even have access to the same software systems.

At this stage of your case I would not recommend contacting anyone at the 800 #. Your attorney's office should be handling all your questions at this point...but if you must contact SS directly, call the local office or the hearing office.

For example, I was told by two different employees at the 800 # that I had received a FF decision, six months apart and that I'd be receiving my benefits and backup at anytime. Unfortunately, they just didn't know how to read my earlier Partially Favorable Decision.

Originally Posted by Rayandnay

I have Binder and Binder, they hate answering questions, I feel like another brick in the wall, that's why I hope this is it, we can all ride off into the sunset.

Originally Posted by Rayandnay

I have Binder and Binder, they hate answering questions, I feel like another brick in the wall, that's why I hope this is it, we can all ride off into the sunset.

Originally Posted by Rayandnay

My problem is that keep drawing judges with very low approval rates, not very intelligent, because the appeals council keeps sending it back. The judge that sent me on my CE exam which included a IQ and Memory Scale exam has 66% approval rating, so I'm cautiously optimistic. My remand order from appeals council only wants one thing cleared up, their doctors words, one says severe, the other says mild to moderate.