KittyLady I used to watch that every single season and I just got tired of it, don't know why. They had some girls with some pretty bad attitudes but yet other reality shows do to and I still watch them.

Yeah, the judges are going for Joshua and Jessica. I don't like either kind of music but I do recognize they have amazing talent. I was even impressed with When a man loves a woman. I do love Hollie, I'm glad she has gone as far as she has. She has learned and grown up so much.

Well Tarzan is gone. All the ladies saw through him. They all knew he was a doctor and didn't need the money. I wonder how they kept him on the show as long as they did.

You're no oddball. I watch it too. I just DVR it cause I like ABC's Wednesday night line up.

Re: Idol, Joshua is the best singer flat out. I was voting for Hollie but switched last night and voted for the "best singer" and that is Joshua. He'll have a career no matter what happens.

Hollie is young and hey, she made it to the top 4. This is where I think she get's off.
ANN

No no, Jessica is the best,,na na na na a na..

Actually either one should win....and which ever one does, the other will get a contract, as well.

Yes, lol, what took those ditzy women so long. It almost makes you wish Colten would come back and win..

I watch these singing shows too, and dancing with stars, voice etc. I know we all have favorites, but I have to tell you I think, all of them are darn good. To sing like they do is truely a gift, and once in awhile when someone is spectacular, it brings tears to my eyes, just to see that talent. What fun it is to watch these young talents do their thing! ginnie

So sad to see Holly gone. But I'm sure will pick her up and offer her a deal. Tonight was the first night I saw Jessica walk with a real attitude. But she is 16 and has become a national pastime in a matter of months.

Well my favorite to win has always been Jessica, but I may have switched allegience to Joshua. He cried all during Holly's closing song.....sooooo sweet.

Jessica will make it no matter what, anyway..

Yes, he cried but was it for Hollie leaving or that he had made it to the final three? I don't like any of the remaining. I'll watch it but I don't like them

You are a cruel woman, Doyds..